The Best Baby Carriers, Tested by Parents and Their Little Ones

When choosing the overall best baby carrier, we looked for a model that excelled in several categories, including ease of use, comfort, healthy positioning, features, style and value for money—and the Ergobaby Omni Breeze Baby Carrier undoubtedly stood out. The infant carrier thoroughly impressed our product tester Brooke, who awarded it a 10 out of 10 across the board, earning it a perfect score and a Best of The Bump award for overall best baby carrier. (See all of this year’s Best of The Bump winners.)

Brooke found this carrier straightforward to use right from the start, thanks to the user-friendly instructions, and a breeze to get her 2-month-old situated in the carrier: “It took me two minutes to figure out how to put it on and get baby in it all by myself,” she said. “Adjusting it was pretty easy—the strap across your shoulders was a little more challenging—but other than that, very simple. My fiancé got it on and adjusted the straps in [just] a minute.” Plus, parents hoping to share this infant carrier will appreciate that it’s one of the most size-inclusive options on our list.

A critical factor to consider when carrier shopping is comfort—and for Brooke, the Ergobaby Omni Breeze excelled in this area. “I wore the carrier to go to a festival, and we were there for four hours. [I] never got uncomfortable with her in it,” she shared. This comfort can be attributed to the baby carrier’s wide crossable shoulder straps and lumbar back support, which Brooke found to be particularly supportive. “Usually, I’m in pain after an hour, but this carrier has so much support in all the right places,” she said. Plus, the carrier features SoftFlex mesh material, which allows for maximum breathability, and a vented waistband that promotes airflow where it’s needed the most. “I was barely sweaty [after] being in 104-degree weather,” Brooke told us. When it’s warm out, you can unfold the hood—located on the front—for sun protection. (Brooke said she also found this handy for keeping baby’s head covered when it started to rain outside!) If that’s not all, Brooke told us she was even able to breastfeed in it. While doing so, she said, “the shoulder straps [were] able to support her head as I supported her neck.”

This top-rated baby carrier has a 4-in-1 design that can be adjusted to accommodate your little one through several ages and stages: Facing in, facing out, hip carry and back carry. No matter which position you’re using, you can ensure the ergonomic seat will keep baby in the hip-healthy M-position. Plus, the one-step adjustment system makes these changes simple, whether you’re carrying a newborn or a toddler. Using the Velcro tabs and color-coded stripes on the waist belt, simply adjust the seat to align with baby’s height. All in all, these top-notch features work together to create a seamless babywearing experience for parents and little ones. We can’t recommend this baby carrier enough!

Weight: 2.5 lbs. | Age range: Newborn to 4 years | Weight capacity: 7 to 45 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 4

Our community says:

When choosing a baby carrier for a newborn, you’ll want to look for a design that’s secure enough to support baby’s head and small frame and adjustable enough to accommodate early growth spurts. BabyBjörn’s Baby Carrier Mini, which is designed especially for newborns, checked both of those boxes on our list—and then some. Our product tester Caitlin used this carrier with her 1-month-old, who she described as “very tiny, 5th percentile,” and she found it straightforward to use, even when her little one was squirming. “I decided to try it when my newborn was screaming his head off, and I expected to struggle putting it together. However, the carrier comes with picture directions that were so easy to use, and the carrier literally took less than three minutes to put together the first time,” she shared. After that first try, Caitlin said it took less than a minute to put on, earning it a 10 out of 10 score for ease of use.

Positioning her infant in this carrier was a breeze for Caitlin, thanks to the user-friendly straps and the sturdy, soft seat. “It’s very easy to get my newborn in his proper position. Normally once he is positioned and buckled in, I don’t need to adjust him at all,” she told us. This newborn carrier also offers adjustable head support that keeps baby snug while they’re facing inwards, plus adjustable leg openings for newborns between 7 to 10 pounds, to ensure a secure fit.

While the BabyBjörn Baby Carrier Mini is ideal for newborns, it’s also suitable for babies up to their first birthday or until they weigh 24 pounds. In fact, the BabyBjörn Mini can be adapted to two carrying positions—inward-facing or outward-facing—to meet your changing needs as baby grows throughout their first year.

It’s available in four super-soft materials (3D jersey, 3D mesh, satin-woven cotton and a woven blend) and ample colorways (ranging from neutrals to cheetah print), so you’re sure to find an option that aligns with your aesthetic. These gentle, lightweight materials will keep you and baby comfy, no matter what you have on your schedule for the day. Caitlin awarded it 10 out of 10 for comfort: “I’ve been wearing it in the 100-degree summer weather, and it’s very breathable!” she shared, adding, “it really doesn’t get overwhelmingly heavy at any point.” In particular, she was a fan of the ventilation this carrier offers, which is an essential quality for newborns who can’t yet regulate their body temperatures.

At the end of the day, Caitlin told us she would highly recommend it to other parents. “The comfort of this carrier and the ease of use is what makes the carrier stand out,” she explained. “Every time I leave the house now, it’s the carrier I grab and will continue to grab.” High praise indeed—no wonder the BabyBjörn Baby Carrier Mini earned a Best of The Bump award for best newborn carrier.

Weight: 1.1 lbs. | Age range: Newborn to 1 year | Weight capacity: 7 to 24 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 2

Our community says:

Can’t decide whether you prefer structured baby carriers or wraps? Luckily, with the Boppy ComfyFit Adjust Hybrid Baby Carrier, you can have the best of both worlds. This Best of The Bump-winning hybrid carrier combines the support and simplicity of a classic structured carrier with a wrap’s flexible, enveloping feel—in fact, it earned 10 out of 10 scores for comfort and ease of use from our product tester Anna, who described it as “the perfect mix of structure plus soft fabric to make sure your back is supported and baby is comfortable on your chest.”

The yoga-inspired fabric is a polyester-spandex blend—so not only is it as stretchy and buttery-soft as your favorite workout apparel, but it can be wrapped to fit a wide range of sizes. No matter who has it on, the elastic material and crossover straps will work to spread baby’s weight evenly across the wearer’s shoulders, and the adjustable, padded waist belt adds extra support. It can also be arranged into three carrying positions, all of which encourage the baby to sit in the hip-healthy M-position.

One of the biggest obstacles parents face with a wrap is the learning curve, but the ComfyFit’s hybrid design makes it easy: “It takes a few times to get the hang of the straps, but having the waist strap and adjustable arm straps makes it easy to get the baby securely in the carrier,” Anna said. “I can easily put it on and off by myself.” Moreover, Anna appreciated how the snug fit kept her 2-month-old at the perfect head-kissing height without fuss. “The carrier itself is secure and does not require repositioning once you have the baby in and the straps tightened,” Anna explained.

Other features you’ll love include the small folded size (making it a useful travel companion), the UPF 50+ material for extra sun protection, the handy storage pocket and that it doesn’t require an infant insert. According to Anna, the ComfyFit offers impressive performance at a price that feels well worth it, giving it a 10 out of 10 score for value. “Similar cloth carriers are much more expensive, and I like that this one gives structure and softness,” she said. “I have had the exact same carrier for many years and it holds up well in the wash and through many wears.” All in all, this hybrid baby carrier combines the best of structured designs and wrap styles, offering a winning solution to parents of all lifestyles.

Weight: 2.4 lbs. | Age range: N/A | Weight capacity: 8 to 35 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 3

Our community says:

Considering you may be wearing a carrier on a daily basis for months on end, comfort is a key quality to look for. The WildBird Willow Aerial Carrier, our Best of The Bump winner for most comfortable baby carrier, thoroughly impressed our product tester Nicole in this area. “Because of the wider shoulder straps, my neck muscles were never in pain like other carriers have caused,” Nicole told us, adding that whether she was headed to the store for a quick shopping trip or spending all day on her oldest daughter’s field trip, “no matter what I have used this for, I have not had any discomfort at all.”

This can be attributed to the premium construction of this carrier, which features a wide, padded waist belt and cushioned shoulder straps, both of which can be adjusted via easy-access side buckles. Better yet, this design offers cross-over straps, which work to evenly distribute baby’s weight across the parents’ shoulders. Made from 100 percent natural linen with a mesh lining and nylon straps, the fabric is breathable and long-lasting. “When testing this in chilly and warmer weather, the material was not hot for myself or baby, [and] protected my baby from the elements as much as possible,” Nicole said.

The WildBird Willow comes in two waistband sizes to ensure a snug, secure fit. This targeted sizing may be an obstacle when two parents are using the same carrier, but Nicole told us she had no problem sharing the Willow Aerial with her partner. “When it came to switching between my partner and myself, it was very easy to make adjustments that fit that person comfortably.” She told us that she experienced a slight learning curve at first and had to practice putting it on a few times, but once she got the hang of it, it was smooth sailing, especially when positioning her 2-month-old. “This carrier made me feel very safe in carrying my baby as it kept her close to me and I never found myself having to readjust her or the straps,” Nicole explained. She was also a fan of the side snaps, which made it easy for her to ensure her newborn was in a hip-healthy position. After all, you’re not the only one who needs to be comfortable in the carrier!

Weight: 2.9 lbs. | Age range: N/A | Weight capacity: 7 to 45 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 2

It’s no secret that using a new baby carrier can be challenging at first, whether you’ve been a parent for days or years. Luckily, the BabyBjörn Harmony Baby Carrier, our Best of the Bump winner for easiest-to-use baby carrier, simplifies the babywearing experience for beginners and pros alike. Some carriers use an upper back clip that might be tricky for some parents to secure independently, but the BabyBjörn Harmony opts instead for an adjustable, non-clip back strap and easy-access buckles that clip in the front. That way, it’s super simple to set up, even when holding your little one. Our product tester Aliez agreed. “The carrier was very easy to figure out and put on. …I didn’t need help with any buckles at all. The straps were easily adjustable and reachable,” she said, adding, “it only took about 10 seconds to adjust all the straps.”

Whether you have a newborn or older baby, the BabyBjörn Harmony Baby Carrier is versatile enough to adapt to your needs. The ergonomic design seamlessly transitions into four carrying positions—newborn, facing in, facing out and on your back—so you can count on it through infancy to toddlerhood. Convenient zippers let you adjust the carrier height and seat width in a matter of seconds based on your child’s size, and a head support panel can flip up or down.

This top-of-the-line baby carrier offers parents total comfort, thanks to its luxe, Scandinavian-inspired craftsmanship. It features a pressure-relieving waist belt and padded back and shoulder straps to support babywearing. “It felt extremely comfortable wearing it for a little over an hour,” Aliez told us. “I didn’t get any muscle or neck pain at all (and I’ve used other carriers that do hurt my lower back).” Plus, you and baby will both appreciate the soft, supportive mesh that’s highly breathable to keep everyone comfy.

It’s no surprise that Aliez awarded this carrier a 10 out of 10 across several categories, including features and ease of use. Furthermore, our survey showed that 15 percent of respondents count on this brand for all of their babywearing needs. “I am definitely running to tell my mommy friends about this carrier!” Aliez gushed.

Weight: 1.9 lbs. | Age range: Newborn to 3 years | Weight capacity: 7 to 41 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 4

The best infant carriers don’t have to cost an arm and a leg. Case in point: The Evenflo Breathable Carrier, which rings in at under $35, making it the most affordable option on our list and our Best of The Bump winner for best budget-friendly baby carrier. This carrier may not have a high price tag, but that doesn’t mean you’ll miss out on standout performance. Our product tester Jessica had high praises for this model from the get-go, awarding it a 10 out of 10 for ease of use and features. “I was able to adjust the carrier on my own with no issues. Getting my baby in and out of the carrier is a breeze without any straining at all,” she explained. This is in part because of the side-entry buckles that audibly click so you know when they’re fastened, among other easy-access details.

Jessica gave this baby carrier 10 out of 10 scores across several categories, including comfort and style. But what really stood out to her was the support it offered to both her and baby. “This carrier feels great to wear! I do have a history of upper back and neck pain, and I feel the carrier helped me keep a better posture while carrying my baby,” she told us. Features like the woven crossover straps work to evenly distribute weight across parents’ shoulders for optimal comfort and stability.

Meanwhile, the carrier’s mesh side panels allow air flow to keep you both cool, even during long-term babywearing sessions. Jessica also appreciated how straightforward it was to position her 1-month-old in this model. “I've noticed that my baby is in a comfortable position immediately when I place him in the carrier. I don't need to readjust him at all,” she shared. Plus, you can count on the built-in padded headrest to gently cradle your little one. “I really love the design of this carrier and how the material comes up higher to help support my newborn's head,” Jessica told us.

The Evenflo can be used from early newborn days to early toddlerhood, up until they reach 26 pounds. As baby grows, it can be adapted to two carrying positions (inward- or outward-facing). What’s more, there’s also a convenient pocket on the front where Jessica said she was able to store everyday essentials, like her cellphone, as well as a removable bib to absorb drool and keep the carrier clean. Overall, she told us that she “would definitely recommend this carrier! It's very lightweight and stylish which I feel most parents would love,” and we definitely agree.

Special offer: Take 15 percent off sitewide when you buy direct from Evenflo with the code BUMP15.

Weight: 8 oz. | Age range: N/A | Weight capacity: 7 to 26 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 2

Our community says:

Searching for a baby carrier that you and your partner can share? Look no further than the BabyTula Explore Carrier. The versatile design is ideal for a wide range of babywearers, due to its highly adjustable, inclusive size. The BabyTula Explore has supportive waistband webbing that fits waists between 27 to 57 inches (whereas most styles only extend to around 53 inches). “I love that there are many adjustable pieces so it fits my body perfectly when my husband and I switch,” our product tester Karina said. This ability to swap back and forth between partners large and small helped the BabyTula Explore win a Best of The Bump award for best baby carrier for partners.

Not only is this carrier easy to swap between caregivers, but it’s equally as easy to swap between kids. “I feel so confident and comfortable putting my 4-month-old and toddler in this carrier,” Karina gushed. “This is hands-down the best quality carrier I’ve tried, and my child always feels secure. Placing my child in the carrier is so easy and there’s no struggle.”

While using this infant and toddler carrier, you can choose from three different carrying positions, including on your front (facing in or out) and on your back. Parents will appreciate details like the ergonomic seat—designed to fit babies from infancy to toddlerhood—and the wide waist belt to support your child’s ever-changing weight. “I love this carrier because it makes my kid feel so light, especially when I’m wearing my toddler on my back. It just feels like a backpack,” she shared.

Karina gave this infant carrier 10 out of 10 scores for ease of use, features and comfort, telling us, “The carrier is cushioned so it [was] super comfortable on all parts of my body and doesn’t cause any strain or pain like I’ve experienced from other baby carriers,” she praised. This carrier helps you carry your kid with ease and look good while doing it. “I LOVE THIS STYLE!” Karina told us. “I got the Agate Tula and it’s so stylish. It’s more of a neutral, which is perfect because my husband and I both use it.” Tula offers tons of print options (we’re talking dozens), so there’s something for everyone. The bottom line: This versatile and chic baby carrier for dads and moms alike will lighten your load, whether you’re at home or on the go.

Special offer: Take 20 percent off when you buy direct from BabyTula with the discount code BUMP20.

Weight: 1.7 lbs. | Age range: Newborn to 3 years | Weight capacity: 7 to 45 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 3

Our community says:

Baby hip carriers are an alternative to structured carriers, thoughtfully crafted to reduce strain on your spine while holding your little one close. They’re relatively new to the babywearing scene—the Tushbaby Hip Carrier, our Best of The Bump winner for best baby hip carrier, debuted just five years ago on an episode of Shark Tank, but the innovative, high-quality design made an immediate splash with parents. It features a memory foam-lined hip seat, supporting baby’s hips by encouraging them to sit in the M-position, and can be adjusted to face-to-face, side-carrying or front-facing carrying styles, as well as to offer support during breastfeeding sessions.

While our product tester Ariana used this infant carrier with her 9-month-old, it also makes for a great toddler carrier. Natalie Gontcharova, mom of one and senior editor at The Bump, regularly uses it with her almost 3-year-old. “Because carrying babies and toddlers can help promote closeness and regulate emotions, it’s a great tool that can replace the stroller without hurting your back,” Gontcharova explains. (Read her in-depth Tushbaby review.)

The Tushbaby’s unique design quickly made a believer out of Ariana, who rated the infant and toddler carrier a 10 out of 10 for comfort. “I was not expecting it to be as comfortable as it was,” she said. “It took all the pressure off my back when I held my baby. I wore it to a girls' lunch—a total of two to three hours—and he felt like a feather the whole time.” Natalie agrees, saying it’s much more comfortable than she thought it would be. “When I carry [my 2-year-old] for long periods of time without a carrier, I often resort to jutting out one hip and messing up my posture, which puts a lot of strain on my lower back and pelvic muscles. The Tushbaby helps me avoid this chiropractic nightmare,” she shared.

Ariana also found it super simple to strap on, giving it a 10 out of 10 for ease of use. “It’s very easy to put on and take off; it’s a simple Velcro and clip,” she explained, adding that it could also be adjusted in seconds when on. Natalie reminds parents to wear the carrier above their natural waist (as per the product’s instruction manual) to alleviate potential back and shoulder pressure and for an optimal babywearing experience.

On-the-go parents will appreciate how this versatile baby carrier doubles as a fanny pack diaper bag. Complete with five pockets, the clever style lets you seamlessly tote all of your (and even some of baby’s) daily essentials. “I love how it had so much storage. I could have left my purse at home and just worn the carrier because it had a spot for my keys, phone, bottles and more,” Ariana told us. Plus, the Tushbaby comes in several fabrics and colorways, so you can find your perfect match. “It’s super stylish and goes with every outfit,” Ariana gushed. “I even got a compliment on it from another mom at the splash park!”

The final verdict: The Tushbaby Hip Seat Carrier is ideal for parents looking for a unique design that promotes closeness and comfort. According to Ariana, “I would definitely recommend the Tushbaby carrier. It allows me to hold my baby without straining my back.” While it doesn’t fully replace the hands-free versatility of a structured baby carrier, it’s a surefire winner for parents who want added support when carrying their little ones.

Weight: 1 lb. | Age range: Newborn to 3 years old | Weight capacity: 8 to 45 lbs. | Number of carrying positions: 3

Our community says: